Hiring subcontractors can help construction businesses take on larger projects, meet deadlines, and expand their services. But subcontractor insurance mistakes can create costly financial and legal complications. Whether you’re a general contractor in Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin, Iowa, or Minnesota, understanding subcontractor insurance requirements is an important part of managing construction-related risks.

Before a subcontractor starts work, general contractors should review certificates of insurance, verify coverage limits, understand additional insured requirements, and check for potential coverage exclusions. A subcontractor’s insurance policy does not automatically protect the general contractor from every claim. Coverage depends on the policy language, contractual agreements, applicable state laws, and the circumstances surrounding a loss.

At Contractors Insurance, a Division of John Scott Insurance, we work with construction professionals to review commercial insurance options and identify coverage considerations associated with subcontractor relationships.

  1. Assuming Every Subcontractor Has Adequate Insurance

One of the most common mistakes general contractors make is assuming that subcontractors carry appropriate insurance simply because they operate an established business.

A subcontractor may have general liability insurance, but the policy limits, exclusions, or covered operations may not align with the work being performed.

For example, a roofing subcontractor may carry general liability coverage but have an exclusion affecting certain roofing operations. If a claim arises from excluded work, the policy may not respond as expected.

What contractors should consider:

  • Requesting proof of insurance before work begins.
  • Reviewing general liability limits and applicable exclusions.
  • Checking whether coverage applies to the subcontractor’s specific operations.
  • Confirming insurance requirements outlined in the construction contract.

Insurance requirements should reflect the project’s scope, contractual obligations, and applicable laws.

  1. Accepting a Certificate of Insurance Without Understanding What It Means

A Certificate of Insurance (COI) is commonly requested before subcontractors begin working on a construction project.

However, a certificate of insurance is evidence of reported coverage, not an insurance policy or a guarantee that a particular claim is covered.

A COI generally summarizes information such as the insurance carrier, policy type, coverage limits, and policy dates. It does not independently create coverage or change policy terms.

For example, a general contractor might receive a certificate showing $1 million in general liability coverage. That certificate alone does not establish whether the general contractor qualifies as an additional insured or whether the policy covers the subcontractor’s specific work.

General contractors should review insurance documentation alongside the applicable contractual requirements and request additional policy information when appropriate.

  1. Overlooking Additional Insured Requirements

One of the most important insurance considerations when hiring subcontractors is additional insured status.

An additional insured endorsement may extend certain liability protections under a subcontractor’s policy to another party, such as a general contractor or project owner.

However, additional insured coverage is subject to the endorsement’s wording, exclusions, and other policy conditions.

Why does additional insured status matter?

Consider a scenario in which a subcontractor’s work contributes to property damage at a construction site. The property owner files a claim involving both the subcontractor and general contractor.

Depending on the circumstances and policy language, an additional insured endorsement may provide certain liability coverage to the general contractor.

Simply listing a general contractor as a certificate holder does not automatically provide additional insured status.

Contractors should consider whether their agreements require additional insured coverage, including ongoing operations and completed operations where applicable.

  1. Failing to Address Workers’ Compensation Requirements

Workers’ compensation insurance is another important consideration when hiring subcontractors.

Requirements vary by state, and the classification of workers, nature of the work, and business structure can affect applicable obligations.

In certain circumstances, a general contractor may face workers’ compensation exposure involving uninsured subcontractors or their employees.

For example, if an uninsured subcontractor’s employee is injured while working on a construction project, questions may arise regarding statutory employer responsibilities, employment classification, and available insurance coverage.

Construction businesses operating across Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Minnesota should pay particular attention to state-specific requirements.

A subcontractor’s status as an independent business does not automatically resolve every workers’ compensation issue.

General contractors should review applicable state requirements and obtain appropriate insurance documentation before work begins.

  1. Ignoring Completed Operations Coverage

A subcontractor’s work-related risks do not necessarily end when a construction project is finished.

Property damage or bodily injury claims may arise months or even years after completed work.

For example, a plumbing subcontractor installs piping in a newly constructed commercial building. Several months after the project is completed, a connection fails and causes significant water damage.

Depending on the circumstances, the subcontractor’s completed operations coverage may become relevant.

What is completed operations coverage?

Products-completed operations coverage, generally included within certain commercial general liability policies, addresses specified bodily injury or property damage claims arising from completed work, subject to policy terms and exclusions.

General contractors should consider how completed operations exposures are addressed in subcontractor agreements and applicable insurance policies.

Additional insured coverage for ongoing operations does not necessarily extend to completed operations.

  1. Assuming the Subcontractor’s Insurance Covers Every Jobsite Risk

Construction projects involve numerous risks, and no single insurance policy addresses every potential loss.

A subcontractor’s general liability policy may respond to certain third-party bodily injury or property damage claims, but it generally does not cover every type of property or financial loss.

For example, general liability insurance typically does not provide first-party coverage for a subcontractor’s stolen tools or equipment.

Other insurance considerations may include:

  • Builders risk insurance: May cover specified physical damage to buildings or structures during construction.
  • Contractors equipment insurance: May cover certain losses involving owned or rented equipment.
  • Commercial auto insurance: Addresses specified vehicle-related liability and physical damage exposures.
  • Professional liability insurance: May be relevant when design, consulting, or other professional services are involved.
  • Umbrella or excess liability insurance: May provide additional liability limits, subject to policy terms.

General contractors should consider how their own insurance policies interact with subcontractor coverage and project-specific insurance arrangements.

  1. Not Reviewing Insurance Requirements When Projects or Subcontractors Change

Construction businesses evolve. A contractor may begin with smaller residential projects and eventually move into commercial construction, larger renovations, or specialized work.

As projects change, insurance considerations may change as well.

A subcontractor who was appropriately insured for one project may not have coverage that aligns with a different type of work.

For example, a subcontractor performing interior painting on residential properties may later accept work involving exterior painting on multistory commercial buildings. The change in operations may introduce different underwriting considerations, exclusions, or contractual insurance requirements.

General contractors should consider reviewing subcontractor insurance documentation when:

  • A new subcontractor is hired.
  • An existing subcontractor takes on different work.
  • A project involves higher contract values or different exposures.
  • Insurance policies renew, expire, or change.
  • Contractual insurance requirements are revised.

Periodic insurance reviews can help identify documentation issues and potential coverage questions before a loss occurs.

What Insurance Should General Contractors Require From Subcontractors?

There is no universal insurance requirement that applies to every subcontractor or construction project.

Appropriate requirements depend on the type of construction work, project location, contractual obligations, and applicable state laws.

The following table highlights common insurance considerations.

Insurance type Why it matters
General liability Addresses certain third-party bodily injury and property damage claims
Workers’ compensation Addresses qualifying employee work-related injuries and illnesses under applicable law
Commercial auto May address vehicle-related liability involving business operations
Umbrella or excess liability May provide additional limits above specified underlying policies
Professional liability May be relevant for design or professional service exposures
Contractors equipment May address specified losses involving tools and equipment

Contractors should consult their insurance representative and legal counsel when establishing contractual insurance requirements.

Subcontractor Insurance Requirements in Michigan and the Midwest

Construction businesses operating in multiple states may encounter different insurance and regulatory requirements.

Contractors Insurance, a Division of John Scott Insurance, serves construction professionals in Michigan and throughout Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Minnesota.

While general liability insurance is a common contractual requirement, the rules surrounding workers’ compensation, contractor licensing, and subcontractor responsibilities can differ among these states.

A contractor working across state lines should consider whether its insurance program addresses operations in each state where work is performed.

This is particularly relevant for construction companies that regularly hire subcontractors outside their home state or take on projects in multiple jurisdictions.

Frequently Asked Questions About Subcontractor Insurance

Does a general contractor need insurance if subcontractors have their own coverage?

Yes, general contractors generally have their own liability exposures even when subcontractors carry insurance. A subcontractor’s policy does not automatically cover every claim involving the general contractor. Applicable contractual requirements and state laws may also affect insurance obligations.

What happens if a subcontractor does not have liability insurance?

An uninsured subcontractor may create additional financial and contractual exposure for the general contractor. Whether the general contractor’s policy responds to a particular claim depends on the policy language and circumstances. Some policies may contain conditions or exclusions related to subcontracted work.

Is a certificate of insurance enough to verify subcontractor coverage?

No. A certificate of insurance provides a summary of reported insurance information but does not replace the policy or endorsements. Contractors may need additional documentation to evaluate specific contractual insurance requirements.

Should subcontractors name general contractors as additional insureds?

Additional insured requirements are common in construction contracts. Whether such status is appropriate, required, or available depends on the agreement, applicable law, and insurance policy. The specific endorsement language determines the scope of any additional insured coverage.

Do subcontractors need workers’ compensation insurance?

Requirements vary by state, business structure, employee status, and other factors. Contractors should review the rules applicable to the state where work is performed rather than assuming the same requirements apply across all six states.

Does general liability insurance cover faulty workmanship?

Commercial general liability insurance generally does not function as a warranty for defective work. However, certain resulting bodily injury or property damage may be covered depending on the policy language, exclusions, applicable law, and circumstances of the claim.

Review Your Contractor Insurance Before Your Next Project

Hiring subcontractors is a routine part of running a construction business, but insurance documentation and contractual requirements deserve attention before work begins.

From general liability and workers’ compensation to additional insured endorsements and completed operations, understanding how different policies may apply can help contractors make more informed business decisions.

Contractors Insurance, a Division of John Scott Insurance, works with contractors in Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Minnesota to discuss commercial insurance options for their construction operations.

Whether you’re hiring your first subcontractor or managing multiple crews across several states, reviewing your insurance program is a practical part of preparing for your next project.

Contact Contractors Insurance, a Division of John Scott Insurance, to discuss your construction business insurance needs.

Call: (888) 266-5120

Online: www.contractorsinsuranceagency.com/contact/

Email: info@contractorsinsuranceagency.com

Coverage availability, terms, conditions, limits, and exclusions vary by insurer and policy. This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice or a determination of coverage. Actual coverage is governed by the applicable insurance policy and the facts of a claim.